Study highlights public investment behind academic publishers’ profits

New research from the University of Sydney has raised questions about the economics of scholarly publishing – finding that public investment typically accounts for more than 95% of the cost of producing a research article.
Two independent studies, published ahead of International Open Access Week, examine both the resources required to produce academic research and the financial performance of the world’s four largest scholarly publishers.
The findings, reported by the University of Sydney, suggest that the scale of public investment in research has been significantly underestimated because previous calculations have not accounted for the full range of activities involved before an article is submitted for publication.
Professor Jane Andrew from the University of Sydney’s School of Accounting, Governance and Regulation, said: “Every published article rests on substantial public investment. Prior research has estimated various components of that investment but never brought them together across the full research process. Our method does that, revealing the scale of the largely unaccounted-for public subsidy to private sector publishers.
“For example, examining one social science article at a US public doctoral university, we produced a conservative estimate of the cost of that research to be US$70,000. The public makes the overwhelming majority contribution to funding this research, but the published article is usually locked behind a paywall.”
Co-author Professor Max Baker, from the University of Sydney Business School, added: “The bigger issue that we should continue to explore is why publishers should substantially profit from a research process to which they provide only a minimum input.”
The first study, The Cost of Knowledge, introduces a methodology for estimating the resources invested in research before publication, including grant applications, ethics approval, data collection, analysis, writing and revision.
The researchers have also developed a free online calculator enabling academics and institutions to estimate the investment associated with their own research outputs.
A second study, How Profitable Are the Big Four Publishers?, examines the financial performance of RELX (Elsevier), Informa (Taylor & Francis), Springer Nature and Wiley between 2005 and 2025.
According to the analysis, the four companies collectively returned US$38.8 billion to shareholders over the period, with academic publishing contributing disproportionately to the profits underpinning those payments.
Academic publishing was more profitable than other activities within the parent businesses in 68 of the 69 company-years examined. In 2025, academic publishing operating margins ranged from 24% to 38%, while the combined operating margin of the largest publishers increased from 14.9% to 27.5% over the period studied.
RELX alone returned US$30.8 billion to shareholders over the two decades. The study found that its annual cash distributions to investors increased more than tenfold, from US$349 million to US$3.63 billion, with shareholder returns equivalent to 95.9% of operating cash flow in 2025.
The findings have attracted criticism from open access advocates concerned about the proportion of research funding ultimately benefiting commercial shareholders.
“This new analysis sharply highlights the way in which commercial companies inappropriately profit from the current academic publishing system and faculty labour,” said Nick Shockey, Associate Executive Director of SPARC – the Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition – which collaborated in the study.
“These findings quantify just how efficient these companies have become in removing billions of dollars from the research ecosystem and returning them as cash to shareholders.”
The researchers argue that the studies provide a basis for examining how public investment in scholarly research compares with the financial returns generated by the publishing industry.
“For 20 years, through a financial crisis and a pandemic, academic publishing has almost always been more profitable than the rest of these companies’ businesses,” said Professor Baker. “Over this time, a substantial proportion of profits is returned to shareholders rather than going back into building better systems for managing the research publication process.”
